
I often feel like my mind never stops. Last night I woke somewhere around midnight to 1 o’clock am, with the thought of illegitimate art, reminding me of an article written in 1965 by Pierre Bourdieu, a French sociologist, who wrote about many things, including art and photography. In an article called “The peasant and photography”.
The article itself is quite boring and written as a research paper. Essentially, Pierre Bourdieu did not believe that either “peasants” were capable of producing valid work, “A frivolous luxury, the practice of photography would for a peasant be a ridiculous barbarism; to indulge in such a fantasy would be rather like a man taking a stroll along with his wife, on a summer evening, as the pensioners of the bourg do: ‘That’s fine for vacationers, those are things of the city. A peasant who would walk around with a camera hanging over his shoulder would be no more than a failed monsieur’ ( Ibid., p. 608. This quotation is also found later in Bourdieu et al. 1990, op. cit., p. 49.) What is even more interesting is that because his view of photography was not able to develop originality, authenticity or, formal vocabulary photography became an interesting format for a certain advanced field of art in the 1960s and 70s. While some art purists still believe photography is not an art form it has become a more legitimate form of art.
Newer photographers seem much more secure in believing their work can rise to the level of art as I see more newer younger photographers say something along the lines of “my photograph, my art”, whereas many more experienced and trained photographers question what is art. For me, one of the reasons I question what may rise to the level of art is that I have, for better or worse, set a certain expectation of my work and what I believe the work of others should be before being considered art. This is a bias I work to overcome when discussing a photograph with other photographers and focus more on what I believe may encourage them to try different techniques and approaches to lead them to a different plane of creativity. A quick internet search of the term, “what is art” leads to 5.14 billion responses. Go out be creative, create your art don’t let others call your art form illegitimate.
















