
Every photograph is edited. Yes, I said it. Oh, you shoot film you say. It is edited. The editing starts with the selection of film, then the selection of the developer, then the paper. Do you shoot jpeg, and straight from the camera? It is edited. The camera decides how the image is processed, you give total control to the camera. You shoot raw and just do an import and basic export, most likely your software adds some basic adjustments.
One of the greatest, in my mind, photographers was Ansel Adams. Ansel Adams did extensive processing of his photographs. One of my favorite quotes from Adams’ book “The Negative” is; “It is important to realize that the expressive photograph (the “creative” photograph) or the informational photograph does not have directly proportional relationship to what we call reality. We do not perceive certain values in the subject and attempt to duplicate them in the print. We may simulate them, if we wish to, in terms of reflection density values, or we may render them in related values of emotional effect. Many consider my photographs to be in the “realistic” category. Actually, what reality they have is in their optical-image accuracy; their values are definitely “departures from reality.” The viewer may accept them as realistic because the visual effect may be plausible, but if it were possible to make direct visual comparison with the subjects, the differences would be startling.” In other words, his photograph, although accepted as realistic, is a huge departure from the actual scene.
This debate about the use of programs like Photoshop happens virtually every day and frankly, it is tiresome. If you don’t want to use it don’t but don’t try to place your standards on me. If I want to use it that is my choice. Regardless of the opinions of the purists, their photographs are also edited they are just edited in a slightly different way. The first composite photographs appeared over 160 years ago!
In the end, it doesn’t matter. Create the image for you and use the tools you wish to use. It’s all good and they are all photographs.



















